This or that stories are one of the easiest ways to get your followers tapping. But let’s be real — the template matters. A boring poll layout can kill the vibe, while an aesthetic this or that story template makes the choice itself feel like a treat. I’ve rounded up 10 beautifully designed templates, each with its own flavor. They were chosen for visual appeal, versatility, and how well they keep the interactive focus without sacrificing style. Whether you’re a blogger, shop owner, or just someone who loves a cohesive feed, there’s a look here for you.
1. Minimalist Marble
If you’re all about clean lines and subtle textures, this minimalist marble this or that template is your go-to. The background is a soft white marble pattern with faint grey veining. The two options sit side by side in thin, rounded rectangles with sans-serif text. The poll sliders are transparent with a tiny marble fill. It’s understated but elevated — perfect for lifestyle influencers who want to ask “Coffee or tea?” without visual clutter. Pair it with a matching aesthetic insta story background for a cohesive set.
2. Pastel Dream
Pastel lovers, this one’s for you. The template uses a gradient of soft pink, lavender, and baby blue. The this and that labels are written in a playful rounded font, each on a separate cloud-like shape. The poll bar is a gentle curve, almost like a smile. Use it for lighthearted questions like “Beach day or pool day?” or “Muffin or donut?” The aesthetic appeal is off the charts, and it’ll make your story stand out in a sea of neon. For more pastel inspo, check out this elegant aesthetic Instagram story template that shares a similar soft palette.
3. Grunge Noir
Channel your inner rebel with a grunge noir this or that template. The background is a dark, grainy texture with distressed edges. Options appear on ripped paper scraps pinned with a virtual safety pin. The font is an edgy typewriter style, and the sliders have a subtle metallic sheen. Perfect for questions like “Tattoo or piercing?” or “Night owl or early bird?” This design draws heavily from the grunge aesthetic story template trend but adds the interactive twist. If you love this vibe, explore more of our grunge aesthetic story template collection.
4. Vintage Polaroid
Retro lovers, get ready. This template mimics a vintage Polaroid photo with a white border and a slightly faded, warm-toned image underneath. The this and that are written in a cursive script on two separate Polaroid frames beside each other. The poll results appear in a little sticky note at the bottom. It’s perfect for nostalgic questions like “Film or digital?” or “Old school or new school?” The warm tones make it cozy and inviting. For a complete vintage look, combine it with an aesthetic insta story template that features film grain.
5. Neon Nights
Want something that pops? This neon themed template uses a dark background (deep navy or black) with vibrant neon borders and text. The two options are highlighted in hot pink and electric blue, with glowing drop shadows. The poll bar is a futuristic line that pulses (in animation, but the static version still looks sleek). Great for nightlife content or questions like “Club or chill?” or “Sushi or tacos?” It’ll grab attention even in a crowded story queue. Don’t miss our other neon-inspired designs in the aesthetic insta story template line.
6. Botanical Green
Nature-inspired and calming, this template features a background of tropical leaves in muted greens. The this and that boxes are shaped like leaf silhouettes — monstera on one side, fern on the other. The font is a clean serif, and the sliders are thin vines. Ideal for wellness influencers or eco-friendly brands asking questions like “Hike or bike?” or “Smoothie or juice?” The organic feel makes it a refreshing addition to any feed. For more nature-themed designs, see our aesthetic discount story template that uses similar green tones.
7. Dark Academia
Dark academia enthusiasts, this template is for you. The background looks like an antique book page with subtle coffee stains. The two options are written in an old-style serif font on parchment-colored panels. The poll bar is a quill pen and inkwell motif. Perfect for bookish questions like “Fiction or non-fiction?” or “Library or café?” It’s sophisticated and moody. Pair it with other scholarly aesthetics from our aesthetic grunge Instagram story template library for a consistent academic vibe.
8. Candy Pop
Bright, fun, and unapologetically sweet — this candy pop template uses a confetti-like background in rainbow pastels. The this and that are written in bubblegum font on lollipop-shaped buttons. The poll results appear in a swirling lollipop pattern. Use it for light, playful questions like “Sweet or sour?” or “Kitten or puppy?” It’s a guaranteed mood booster and perfect for younger audiences or brands with a playful voice.
9. Clean Corporate
For a more professional or minimalist look, this clean corporate template uses a solid white background with a subtle line pattern. The options are in sleek, sans-serif font on thin horizontal bars. The poll slider is a simple line that highlights the chosen side. Great for business owners asking “Remote or office?” or “Email or call?” It’s subtle enough to not distract from the question, yet still aesthetically pleasing. If you need more professional options, our aesthetic insta story background collection offers complementary clean designs.
10. Watercolor Wash
Finish with a splash of art. This watercolor template features a soft, blended background of blues and purples that look like wet paint. The this and that labels are written in a hand-drawn font on splotches of color. The poll bar is a paintbrush stroke. Perfect for creative questions like “Abstract or realism?” or “Museum or gallery?” It’s artistic and dreamy. For more watercolor-inspired stories, check out the aesthetic insta story template category for similar fluid designs.
There you have it — 10 aesthetic this or that story templates that blend beauty and interactivity. Whether you’re into minimalist marble, grunge noir, or candy pop, there’s a design that’ll make your followers want to tap. The best part? You can mix and match these with other templates from our site to create a whole aesthetic story set. So go ahead, pick your favorite this or that template, and start engaging your audience in style.
